This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it.
-
This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it. I guess resistance is futile.
No, you weren’t hit by 50,000 volts
A rant about the misuse of scientific units
Bad Astronomy Newsletter (badastronomy.beehiiv.com)
@badastro I won a Scrabble game at MIT by pointing out that I could play "NEWTON" as the term for a unit of force, not a person's name.
-
This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it. I guess resistance is futile.
No, you weren’t hit by 50,000 volts
A rant about the misuse of scientific units
Bad Astronomy Newsletter (badastronomy.beehiiv.com)
Good writeup. I was once hit by a 15,000 volt capacitor, but don't know the actual voltage that went through my upper body. Perhaps a hundred volts between two points... It was a very loud explosion and left me totally blind for a few minutes, soaked with sweat, very sore muscles, but still aware I was standing. Interestingly, no burn marks or identifiable injuries. I measured 7000 volts left on the capacitor when my vision came back and finished up my work...
-
This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it. I guess resistance is futile.
No, you weren’t hit by 50,000 volts
A rant about the misuse of scientific units
Bad Astronomy Newsletter (badastronomy.beehiiv.com)
@badastro Model trains usually run at 12v (at full speed). But you can put your fingers on the tracks, and nothing will happen. A 12v car battery, on the other hand.
-
This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it. I guess resistance is futile.
No, you weren’t hit by 50,000 volts
A rant about the misuse of scientific units
Bad Astronomy Newsletter (badastronomy.beehiiv.com)
@badastro But.... I find that talking about electricity via analogies to other forces, like gravity, or moving fluids in pipes, are helpful a bit, but always break down. Electricity is it's own thing.
-
This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it. I guess resistance is futile.
No, you weren’t hit by 50,000 volts
A rant about the misuse of scientific units
Bad Astronomy Newsletter (badastronomy.beehiiv.com)
@badastro OMG this is awesome, but I have to admit I was one of those using the nonsensical units and I should know better. I'm going to go sit in the corner and sob with my shame now.

-
@badastro Model trains usually run at 12v (at full speed). But you can put your fingers on the tracks, and nothing will happen. A 12v car battery, on the other hand.
@14mission I have held both terminals of a car battery many times. As with the model railway, you don't feel anything. How can it electrocute you?
@badastro -
This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it. I guess resistance is futile.
No, you weren’t hit by 50,000 volts
A rant about the misuse of scientific units
Bad Astronomy Newsletter (badastronomy.beehiiv.com)
@badastro Since decibels are a measure based on a reference, I propose a dBAU referenced to the AU. Then you could say that the car is about -208 dBAU away.
-
This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it. I guess resistance is futile.
No, you weren’t hit by 50,000 volts
A rant about the misuse of scientific units
Bad Astronomy Newsletter (badastronomy.beehiiv.com)
Excellent write-up.
Maybe you could have added that volts x amperes is power, which is energy per unit time. So a high value of volts x amperes (watts or kilowatts) hitting a person implies that person getting zapped by a large amount of energy in an instant. (I am ignoring nuances of DC/AC current, the basic point still holds.)
We should start talking about getting hit by so many kilowatts of electrical power!
-
This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it. I guess resistance is futile.
No, you weren’t hit by 50,000 volts
A rant about the misuse of scientific units
Bad Astronomy Newsletter (badastronomy.beehiiv.com)
@badastro We had an optics table in the lab that housekeeping kept dusting… and knocking mirrors out of alignment. So we put up a sign that read “Danger! 10,000 Ohms”. Problem solved, except that the lowest-ranking grad student had to dust it.
-
This has bugged me for years but I only just now finally got around to writing about it. I guess resistance is futile.
No, you weren’t hit by 50,000 volts
A rant about the misuse of scientific units
Bad Astronomy Newsletter (badastronomy.beehiiv.com)
@badastro "So, the higher the rock is dropped from, the more force it can exert."
Terminal velocity joined the chat.
-
@14mission I have held both terminals of a car battery many times. As with the model railway, you don't feel anything. How can it electrocute you?
@badastro@greenpete @badastro Ok, read around.
Looks like 12v isn't enough to overcome the resistance of your skin.
If your hands were *really* wet there might be some danger.
If the terminals were close enough to touch both with your tongue as when testing a 9v battery--you wouldn't want to do that!
Well thanks. -
@badastro "So, the higher the rock is dropped from, the more force it can exert."
Terminal velocity joined the chat.
@mariejulien Asteroid impacts waiting to reply