@SJohnRoss Sorry - should have cut you!
W
wightbred@dice.camp
@wightbred@dice.camp
Posts
-
I must admit that the response to that Quinns review has rather depressed me. -
I must admit that the response to that Quinns review has rather depressed me.@Tim_Eagon @kevin @SJohnRoss @Taskerland Watching it did inspire me to immediately play a similar world, but it didn’t make me want to buy the product, and I played that world with an easier GM toolkit.
-
I must admit that the response to that Quinns review has rather depressed me.@Tim_Eagon @kevin @SJohnRoss @Taskerland Id say it was pretty balanced review based on real play experience: creative world; evocative presentation; fun experience for players to play; but deliberately over complicated rules to fit that world make it harder to GM. I think the problem is that this is an innovate game that won a bunch of awards and that people love, so even loving criticism can look like a kick in the face. Essentially an issue with the maturity of RPG review discourse.
-
I must admit that the response to that Quinns review has rather depressed me.@kevin @SJohnRoss @Taskerland @Tim_Eagon
The latest Indie RPG Newsletter refer to some tension about this review on Discords that couldn’t be linked to: https://ttrpg.in/2025/09/21/triangulation/I did the same and looked and the video comments, but it was all pretty positive about the quality of the review.