Look I think we all know this is terrible...

But.. imagine if the only pack available was the "BokPak and Cats"

@Taskerland @Tim_Eagon

@Printdevil @Tim_Eagon They're going to ruin this place.

What's specifically different about a quote post that isn't just quoting someone with quote marks, is it just easier?

@Taskerland @Tim_Eagon

What's specifically different about a quote post that isn't just quoting someone with quote marks, is it just easier?

@Taskerland @Tim_Eagon

Are these changes reactions to the huge numbers of X and Bluesky people who want things, and not a reflection of what Masto users enjoy?

@Taskerland @Tim_Eagon

What's specifically different about a quote post that isn't just quoting someone with quote marks, is it just easier?

@Taskerland @Tim_Eagon

@Printdevil Quote posts means being able to boost someone's post and add a comment at the top. I think it's a nice feature, you can say why you are boosting.

@Taskerland @Tim_Eagon

@strangequark And antique blunderbusses look wonderful above the fireplace until your neighbour annoys you in just the right way. Combine that with sheer weight of numbers and it's *blam* *blam* *blam* all day long. @Printdevil @Tim_Eagon

@Printdevil Evidently the CEO of bluesky has been melting down over Jesse Singal of all people and there may be a migration taking place. Implementing horrible but familiar features from bluesky is about drawing new people in. @Tim_Eagon

@Taskerland @Printdevil @Tim_Eagon quote posts appear to be important to a lot of Mastodon users. I’ve only felt the lack of them less than a handful of times in several years. They do appear important to black users for the sake of callbacks.
.
Personally not looking forward to quote posts, but hopefully they get implemented with a Mastodonian twist or two. And hopefully they will serve the need for the populations that do expect a benefit.

@Da_Gut My life experience makes it impossible for me to be that optimistic. @Printdevil @Tim_Eagon

@Taskerland @Da_Gut @Printdevil There are some differences between the classic Twitter implementation and what Mastodon is appearing to do. Cosmetically, the original post appears first and then the quote is underneath it. More importantly, you can determine who can actually quote you (the 4.4 settings are available now and are Anyone, Followers, or Just Me).

I assume there is some mechanic in Masto to just "block quote posts"

It seems a very mastodon thing to include?

@Taskerland @strangequark @Tim_Eagon

@Printdevil @Taskerland @strangequark @Tim_Eagon

I'm not sure about the app, but I think the web interface has already inserted this option into the Other Preferences menu. You can choose who you allow to quote your posts.

@Printdevil The problem is that it makes it really simple to 'dunk' on people... Being performatively rude and/or horrible to someone in front of your followers while also sending them after the dunkee. @Tim_Eagon

@Taskerland @Printdevil @Tim_Eagon This right here. I know that Twitter's quislings (pre-Musk) claimed that was a minority usage from their data, but it was **not** the minority of what was in my feed or what they were used for against me.

As soon as any of my instances update to 4.5 I immediately hard-disable quote posts for me. If I can't, I drop Mastodon.

@ZDL @Taskerland @Printdevil Here's the setting in the web app Preferences

@Tim_Eagon @Taskerland @Printdevil My other account has that setting apparently, but this one (v4.2.8) doesn't.

My options looked different from my other account though:

@ZDL @Taskerland @Printdevil Not sure how it's going to work in v4.2.8, but it seems pretty similar to the 4.4.5 version.