The die need to warm up. I have to practice my release to make sure of a good number. Don’t take this from me.

My mother used to tell me there was always one weirdo on every bus. I couldn’t find them.

A properly weighted die

This kind of thinking is wasteful. Every d20 has a finite lifespan. It was created, and it will, at some time in the future be destroyed, as all things are. That means it has a finite number of rolls in its lifetime, with an equal distribution of all possible outcomes. When you “practice roll” and get a nat 20, you have wasted one of the limited number of nat 20s that die has in it. Think of the 20s. Don’t practice roll.

How did you manage to spell the same word differently in the same sentence?

On the contrary, it will not be the number of rolls that destroys it, but being thrown away. You should roll it as much as you can before then, any time spent not rolling is time wasted!

Ai probably

This is like a common house fly worrying about the lifespan of Cthulhu.

Right but the way I took the meme was that you would roll until you get a 1, then deciding the next roll is the “real” one.

That’s what the meme says, but probability doesn’t work that way. If you want the result from a roll, what you’ve roller before has no bearing on the result from this roll. Thus the chance for a single d20 roll is always 1/20, or 5%.

Monty Hall would love this guy

You haven’t seen how some of the folks I play with roll.

It literally doesn’t matter whether you stick with your door or switch.

Takes mathematical model and shoves it in the trash

No! I won’t listen! It doesn’t matter, I tell you!!!

If you’re having an unlimited number of rolls prior to your “real” roll

You’d end up with a perfectly smooth D20 which would never stop rolling, assuming it was rolled in a vacuum.

Okay, normally, sure. But what if I cross my fingers and kick my heels and rub my lucky clover?

Man there’s something about the monty hall problem that just messes with human reasoning. I get it now and it’s really not even complicated at all but when you first learn about it you tend to overthink it. Now I don’t even understand how I was ever confused.

Are you being facetious, or do you want a non-mathematical explanation?

i assume revenge for stepping on a d4 once?

The trick is to say “this is just a practice roll” where the die can hear you, but wink at the GM so they know it’s the real roll. That way, the die will be a spiteful little punk and throw out the nat20 for the “practice”.

But don’t do that too often, or the die will figure out the trick.

then it’s 4% each result. you don’t want to know what happens with the missing 20%.