Skip to content
  • 0 Votes
    1 Posts
    3 Views
    Jürgen HubertJ
    #writerscoffeeclub 20 Sep: How might your work be seen as a criticism of the present moment?Oh boy. Let's do this.Among other things, #folklore is the study of folk narratives - how they arise and spread. Often such are harmless or even fun, but sometimes they are very harmful indeed. Consider how many German folk tales spread and reinforced #antisemitism . Or how many bad things that happened to people or animals were ascribed to witchcraft - people did not have the knowledge to explain, say, cattle diseases as a natural cause, so they came up with a narrative that blamed a harmless old woman in the village who might have suffered from dementia.People got _killed_ by many such folk narratives. And they still do.Contemplate many folk narratives of today - how they are created and how they are spread in both offline channels and on social media. The modern world is an enormously complex place that contains many frightening things - so a lot of people will listen to the first simple narrative they hear, as long it identifies a target for their fears. And then the body count rises.So I study folklore, and talk about it, but I do not assume that such studies are only relevant to the 19th century folk tales I translate. Indeed, the more I learn about this subject, the more I feel that this is vital to understanding how the modern world works - and, perhaps, how to counter some of the most vile narratives out there.Though sometimes the links between old folklore and new folklore are more obvious. For instance, there is now a widespread narrative that pregnant women using painkillers causes their children to develop autism.Now consider the following fragment from a 19th century German text:"If a mother uses a spell in order to ease her birth, then the Evil Enemy tries to lure these children in particular..."https://wiki.sunkencastles.com/wiki/Witches_and_Trudes
  • 0 Votes
    1 Posts
    1 Views
    Jürgen HubertJ
    Here is your irregular reminder that reactionaries in the so-called "Western World" have their own shitty reasons to support the ethnic cleansing perpetrated by the government of #Israel - there is absolutely no good reason to stoop to #antisemitism and "Jewish World Conspiracy" fantasies, and many good reasons not to.Even beyond loons like the so-called "Christian Zionists" who want to restore Israel "to its historical borders" in order to proceed on their checklist for the End of the World, there are sane-but-evil reasons to support the government of Israel. Many of these people are _heavily_ invested in the "Clash of Culture" narrative, and they _need_ Muslims as an "external enemy". For them, this conflict is great, because it alienates Muslims and the "Westen World" from each other.I mean, when any of these people talk about "Judeo-Christian Values" - do you honestly believe that they give a shit about actual Jews? They are just happy that they can use this conflict to go after Muslims - including those who hold the same citizenship as they do. Presumably, purges of the Muslim populations of their countries is one of their end goals, although no doubt they will look for new targets once this is accomplished.So when you want to criticize the government of Israel, _say_ "the government of Israel" - and not "Jews". And credit the other governments who support Israel with their own agency and hold _them_ accountable for their choices rather than using antisemitic narratives.